| Replication
issues || New
as of 3/26/04 || New as of 4/2/04
AVID
replication info
AVID
Online Contact AVID Online for replication information.
Local AVID -- Catherine Franke is listed as AVID person at Santa
Cruz High This
page from UCSC talks about UCSC-AVID partnership.
Ramona
High School "The AVID program is ... noteworthy for its
attention to maintaining integrity of the program in its replication
and dissemination. The literature on innovative programs is replete
with examples of highly effective programs that deteriorate in
the process of being adapted in other settings to the point of
being recognizable in name only. An infrastructure of professional
development support for AVID dissemination has been developed
through regional centers in California." Other information
on this site concerns the program's successes, and studies that
have been done, e.g., "Mehan et al. state that 'AVID coordinators
are engaged in an explicit socialization process in their classrooms
that parallels the implicit socialization process that occurs
in well-to-do families.' (p. 10). Mehan et al. state further that
'AVID coordinators explicitly teach aspects of the implicit culture
of the classroom and the hidden curriculum of the school. Furthermore,
they mediate the relationship between families, high schools,
and colleges by serving as advocates and sponsors of AVID students.'
(Ibid.)
Possible
to identify some experts, some individuals experienced with replications?
Some possible routes for doing that, in addition to contacting
AVID:
EdGateway
Discussions -- There are currently (3/15/04) 260 ongoing
discussions; or start your own! Requires registration (free).
Institute
of Education Sciences and its What Works Clearinghouse at
ED.gov
Lundblad,
Jennifer P, "A Review and Critique of Rogers' Diffusion of
Innovation Theory as it Applies to Organizations." Organization
Development Journal. Winter 2003. Vol. 21, Iss. 4; pg. 50
I printed out a copy of this article, and gave it to you on 3/19/04
Wejnert,
Barbara. " Integrating Models of Diffusion of Innovations:
A Conceptual Framework." Annual Review of Sociology;
2002, Vol. 28 Issue 1, p297, 30p I printed out a copy
of this article, and gave it to you on 3/19/04
ERIC
materials (Educational Research Information Center)
ERIC Digest
Transformative
Learning in Adulthood
AVID
There are hundreds of reports and articles on AVID. None, that
I found, specifically on replication. Here's brief information
on three that are evaluations of AVID --
ED472171
The AVID Program in AISD, 1999-2002.
Author Oswald, Kim Johnson
Pagination 21
Publication Date 2002-12-00
Publication Type Reports - Evaluative
Advancement via Individual Determination (AVID) is a program designed
to help underachieving students with academic potential prepare
for entrance into colleges and universities. An evaluation of
the AVID program was conducted to determine program effects. ......
[Austin Independent School district)
ED465771
The AVID Program in AISD: Program Evaluation Report, 2000-2001.
Author Oswald, Kim Johnson
Pagination 36
Publication Date 2002-03-00
Publication Type Reports - Evaluative
"As the demonstration grant that started AVID comes to an
end, and AVID becomes integrated into AISD, it is important to
evaluate program operation and participants' success."
ED474012
The Magnificent Eight: AVID Best Practices Study. Final
Report.
Author Guthrie, Grace Pung;Guthrie, Larry F.
Pagination 59
Publication Date 2002-02-00
The AVID Best Practices Study assessed the relative efficacy of
11 AVID program essentials; examined schoolwide effects of AVID;
and identified necessary research-based changes in AVID program
essentials or staff development. ...
Replication
as a topic
ED467568
Lessons Learned: What the WAY Program Can Teach Us about
Program Replication.
Author Baker, Amy, J. L.;Dale, Nan;Racine, David
Pagination 48
Publication Date 2002-05-00
Publication Type Reports - Evaluative
This report describes challenges, opportunities, and pitfalls
that exist when attempting to replicate successful youth programs,
focusing on the replication of a program originally developed
by the Children's Village, Dobbs Ferry, New York. The program
was designed to motivate youth in the child welfare system's residential
treatment program to stay in school and develop and practice sound
work ethics after discharge from care. The program, "Work
Appreciation for Youth," was implemented by four community-based
organizations with out-of-school youth living in their own communities.
Examination of the replication process suggests a number of key
issues for consideration by administrators and practitioners of
replication sites, sponsoring agencies, and funders. Findings
highlight the fact that identifying successful program models
and promoting replications is only part of the challenge. Successful
replications require careful consideration of several key issues
by the replicating site, sponsoring agency, and funding agency
(e.g., establishing a mutually agreed-upon quality control mechanism
for replication sites before starting; ensuring broad, high-level
organizational commitment to the program; developing an implementation
manual; making sure programs are large enough; allowing for extended
startup time; and facilitating ongoing funding). (SM)
New
as of 3/26/04 Public/Private
Ventures, Section on Replication & Expansion. David P. Racine
has written "Investing in What Works" that's available
on this Web site. I printed it out for you. Very good piece, I think.
I'd suggest you subscribe to get email updates on replication (to
do so, go to the Web site). Could you please look over this
page of publications and tell me which ones you would want to
have downloaded? I've looked up David P. Racine (and David Racine)
in databases, and don't see that he has other publications. I'm
ordering an article he published last year in Nonprofit and
Voluntary Sector Quarterly on interlibrary loan for you. Public/Private
Ventures has an Oakland Office! --
Lake Merritt Plaza
1999 Harrison Street
Suite 1550
Oakland, CA 94612
Phone: 510-273-4600
Fax: 510-273-4619
New
as of 4/03/04
Racine, David.
"Dissolving Dualities: The Case for Commonsense Replication."
Nonprofit and Voluntary Sector Quarterly, vol. 32, 2,
June 2003, p. 307-314. I gave you a copy of this article on 4/2/04.
Racine
refers to Winter's article "Replication as Strategy"
in his bibliography.
Winter,
Sidney G., and Gabriel Szulanski. "Replication as
Strategy." Organization Science, vol. 12,
6, Nov/Dec 2001, p. 730+ I printed out this article for you. Talks
about "the broad scope of knowledge transfer," and discusses
a "theory of replication strategy," but (my own take)
the focus is on franchising. One key idea may be useful: the "Arrow
Core" (named after Kenneth Arrow, Nobel Prize winner in economics
for his theories about information economics), which is information
about "which traits are replicable, how these attributes
are created, and the characteristics of environments in which
they are worth replicating" (see p. 6 of the printed out
article). The Arrow core concept might be quite helpful, I think,
to your work. [Using "Arrow core" as a search term only
turned up business or organizational science articles that are
far from the content in which you're interested; at least so far.]
America's
Choice "The
America's Choice® School Design is the result of our extensive
study of the best educational practices in the U.S. and abroad.
The aim of the design is to ensure that every student is successful
on state and local assessments and prepared for college. The design
complies in every respect with the requirements of the federal
No Child Left Behind Act of 2001." I printed out their America's
Choice School Design: A Research-Based Model document for
you. A proposal to adopt America's Choice in Monterey (CA) was
turned down in a 4-3 vote in May 03. I printed out this news story
for you -- author is Friedrich.
New
American Schools --their Web site. Commentary
on New American Schools:
Berends, Mark et al. Facing the Challenges of Whole-School
Reform: New American Schools after a Decade. Santa
Monica, CA: RAND Education, 2002. I got this book on ILL. I photocopied
sections for you-- Summary, NAS's "Theory of Action;"
"implications for Future Efforts."
Berends, Mark et al. "Looking Back Over a Decade
of Whole-School Reform: The Experience of New American Schools."
Phi Delta Kappan, vol. 84, 2, Oct. 2002, p. 168+ I printed
this article out for you. Good outline of origin (NAS worked with
RAND) and conceptual framework. Reports on a study of NAS schools.
Some good "Implications for Future Reform Efforts,"
p. 9+ of the printout.
Success
for All -- their Web site. Commentary on
Success for All: There has been considerable controversy over
the claims made for Success for All. Slavin is adament that it
is successful; his critics bring up questions about the evaluation
research that's been done. I printed out some of these articles
-- Slavin (2 articles), Baker (1 article, it's a review of a Slavin
and Madden book; read this to get an overview); Pogrow (1 article;
Pogrow is repeatedly critical of Slavin-- excerpt from the abstract
of this article: "there is now a large and consistent set
of independent studies concluding that there is no effect from
Success for All, New American Schools, or any other schoolwide
reform model.")
New as of 4/28/04
Kirby, Sheila
Nataraj et al. Implementation in a Longitudinal Sample
of New American Schools: Four Years into Scale-Up.
RAND Education, 2001. I borrowed this on ILL; it came; I photocopied
sections for you, including the bibliography. "Between the
fourth and fifth years...we found a significant downturn in implementation."
(from the summary, p. xv)
|
Affective
education Transition
to Adulthood ||
New as
of 3/26/04 || New as of 4/25/04 and
4/26/04 || New as of 5/6/04
-- this section includes materials about neuroscience and learning
Caldwell,
Leon D. and Siwatu, Kamau O. "Promoting Academic
Persistence in African American and Latino High School Students:
The Educational Navigation Skills Seminar." High
School Journal, Oct/Nov2003, vol. 87 Issue 1, p30, 9p. On
Academic Search Elite. I gave you a copy of this article.
Chavkin,
Nancy Feyl and John Gonzales. Mexican Immigrant Youth
and Resiliency: Research and Promising Programs. Summarizes
resiliency literature; lists promising programs. ERIC Digest.
EDO-RC-00-1; 2000010 I printed this out for you.
Conchas,
Gilberto Q. "Structuring Failure and Success: Understanding
the Variability in Latino School Engagement." Harvard
Education Review fol. 71, 3, Fall 2001, p. 475+ I printed
this out for you.
Gibson, Margaret
A. Improving Graduation Outcomes for Migrant Students.
Addresses "factors supporting student success." ERIC
Digest. EDO-RC-03-2 200307. I printed this out for you. Dr.
Gibson is a prof of education and anthropology at UCSC.
ggibson@cats.ucsc.edu; 831.459.4740
Gloria, Alberta
M. and Tamara A. Ho. "Environmental, Social, and
Psychological Experiences of Asian American Undergraduates: Examining
Issues of Academic Persistence." Journal of
Counseling and Development, vol. 81, 1, Winter 2003, p. 93+
Article is about Asian Americans, but reviews lit about academic
persistence; discusses College Self-Efficacy Inventory (CSEI)
I printed this out for you.
McCombs, Barbara L. "Reducing the Achievement
Gap." Society Jul/Aug2000, Vol. 37 Issue
5, p29, 8p. On Academic Search Elite.
I gave you a copy of this article.
Similar
programs
KIPP
Knowledge Is Power Program Has
just received a grant of nearly $8 million from the Bill and Melinda
Gates Foundation. (Newsweek 22 March 2004, p. 12)
Special
topic: Procrastination/Not
completing tasks
Haycock, Laurel A. et al. "Procrastination in College
Students: The Role of Self-Efficacy and Anxiety." Journal
of Counseling and Development, vol. 76, Summer 1998, p. 317+
I printed this out for you.
Misra, Ranjita,
et al. "College Students Academic Stress and its
Relation to Their Anxiety, Times Management, and Leisure Satisfaction."
American Journal of Health studies, vol. 16, 1, 2000,
p. 41+ I printed this out for you.
Journals
Journal of Transformative Education and its Tables
of Contents
Journal
of Education for Students Placed at Risk
Bilingual
Research Journal
-- worth exploring, anyway. For example, there's a review (Spring
2002 issue) of Reyes and Scribner's Lessons from High-Performing
Hispanic Schools: Creating Learning Communities.
Books
you listed, with Amazon.com sales ranks from 3/16/04.
None of them are best sellers. I have not yet independently looked
for best sellers for this kind of book, but the rank gives you
some indication. NOTE: The Stone, Patton, Heen book is
no. 247!
Dalton, Jane.
The Compassionate Classroom: Lessons that Nurture Wisdom and
Empathy. Tucson, Ariz.: Zephyr Press, 2003. Amazon sales
rank: 2,125,946
Greenspan,
Stanley I. The Growth of the Mind: and the Endangered Origins
of Intelligence. Reading, MA: Perseus Books, 1998. Amazon.com
sales rank: 60,505
Lantieri,
Linda, ed. Schools with Spirit: Nurturing the Inner Lives
of Children and Teachers. Boston: Beacon Press, 2001. Amazon.com
sales rank: 358,384
Macbeth,
Fiona and Nic Fine. Playing with Fire: Creative Conflict Resolution
for Young Adults. Philadelphia, PA: New Society Publishers,
1995. Amazon.com sales rank: 203,292
Miller, William
R. Quantum Change: When Epiphanies and Sudden Insights Transform
Ordinary Lives. New York: Guilford Press, 2001. Amazon.com
sales rank: 93,483
Stone, Douglas,
and Bruce Patton, and Sheila Heen.Difficult Conversations:
How to Discuss What Matters Most. New York: Viking, 1999.
Amazon.com sales rank: 247
Vella, Jane
Kathryn. Training through Dialogue: Promoting Effective Learning
and Change with Adults. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass, 1995.
Amazon.com sales rank: 136,936
Other
books on affective education that might be of interest?
Cohen,
Jonathan, ed. Educating Minds and Hearts: Social Emotional
Learning and the Passage into Adolescence. Alexandria, VA:
Association for Supervision and Curriculum Development, 2003.
Amazon.com sales rank: 119,147
Eisler, Raine
Tennenhaus. Tomorrow's Children: A Blueprint for Partnership
Education in the 21st Century. Boulder, CO: Westview Press,
2000. Amazon.com sales rank: 145,344
Haynes, Norris M., et al., eds. How Social and Emotional
Development Add Up: Getting Results in Math and Science Education.
New York: Teachers College Press, 2003. Amazon.com sales rank:
941,873
Kessler,
Rachael. The Soul of Education: Helping Students find Connection,
Compassion, and Character at School. Alexandria, VA: Association
for Supervision and Curriculum Development, 2000. Amazon.com sales
rank: 96,437
Mapes, Katta.
Stop! Think! Choose!: Building Emotional Intelligence in Young
People. Tucson, Ariz.: Zephyr Press, 2000. Amazon.com sales
rank: 648,551
Novick, Bernard.
Building Learning Communities with Character: How to Integrate
Academic, Social, and Emotional Learning. Alexandria, VA:
Association for Supervision and Curriculum Development, 2002.
Amazon.com sales rank: 611,660.
Pasi, Raymond
J. Higher Expectations: Promoting Social Emotional Learning
and Academic Achievement in Your School. New York: Teachers
College Press, 2001. Amazon.com sales rank: 478,836
Reyes, Pedro,
Jay D. Scribner, and Alicia Paredes Scribner, eds. Lessons
from High-Performing Hispanic Schools : Creating Learning Communities
New York : Teachers College Press, c1999. Amazon.com sales
rank: 159,189
Rompelman,
Lynne. Affective Teaching. Lanham, MD: University Press
of America, 2002. Amazon.com sales rank: 1,755,148.
Zins, Joseph
E., et al., ed. Building Academic Success on Social and Emotional
Learning: What Does the Research Say? New York: Teachers
College Press, 2004. 2,016,759
New
as of 3/26/04
Allexasht-Snider, Martha, and Hart, Laurie E. "'Mathematics
for all'" How Do We Get There?" Theory into
Practice, vol. 40, 2, Spring 2001, p. 93+ I printed this out
for you. "...integrating the concepts of engagement and a sense
of belongingness for underrepresented students in the mathematics
classroom is an important new idea..." p. 8-9
Valenzuela,
Angela. "Mexican-American Youth and the Politics
of Caring," Chapt. 11 p.322-350) in Elizabeth Long,
ed. From Sociology to Cultural Studies: New Perspectives
Blackwell Publishers, 1997. Summary of literature on
caring as it relates to students and teachers. I printed this
out for you. (I borrowed the bk on ILL)
Transition
to Adulthood
Network on Adult Transitions
funded by the MacArthur Foundation
Furstenberg, Frank E. "The Sociology of Adolescence
and Youth in the 1990s: A Critical Commentary."
Journal of Marriage & the Family;, vol. 62, 4, Nov.
2000, p. 896+ Cites the studies from the 1990s. Good overview.
I printed this out for you.
Wells, Thomas,
et al. "What Happens after the High School Years
among Young Persons with Disabilities?" Social
Forces, vol. 82, 2, Dec. 2003, p. 803+ I printed this out
for you.
New
as of 4/25/04
Barinaga,
Marcia. "A Critical Issue for the Brain."
Science, vol. 288, 23 June 2000, p. 2116. Discusses the
issue as to whether there are "critical periods" in
brain development (e.g., the notion that learning in the first
3 years of life constitutes a "critical period"). I
printed this out for you.
Bruer,
John T. "In Search of...Brain-Based Education."
Phi Delta Kappan, vol. 80, 9, May 1999, p. 648 "Brain
science appears to give hard biological data and explanations
that, for some reason, we find more compelling than the 'soft'
data that come from psychological science. But seductive appeal
and a very limited brain science database are a dangerous combination."
I printed this out for you.
Chance, Paul
"The Brain Goes to School." Psychology
Today 34, 5, Sep/Oct 2001, p. 72+ Reviews Eric Jensen's Brain-Based
Learning (2d ed.), For the Learner's Sake: Brain-based
Instruction for the 21st Century, by Judy Stevens and Dee
Goldberg; How the Brain Learns by David A. Sousa.These
books, the reviewer says, use "the prestige of neuroscience..."
to promote teaching ideas. I printed this out for you.
DiPietro,
Janet A. "Baby and the Brain: Advances in Child Development."
Annual Review of Public Health 21, 2000, p.
455-471. "Most recently, neurobiologic information on brain
function and structure has been used to promote strategies for
optimizing child development. This review will evaluate the current
state of knowledge relating early child development to brain research
and illustrate the potential misuse of this information."
I printed this out for you.
Dwyer, Brian.
"Successful Training Strategies for the Twenty-First
century: Using Recent Research on Learning to Provide Effective
Training Strategies." The International Journal
of Educational Management, vol. 15, 6/7, 2001, p. 312+ "Now
is the time and the opportunity to examine the training model
to ensure that it embraces brain-based learning, multiple intelligence
and emotional intelligence..." I printed this out for you.
Green, Fara
R. "Brain and Learning Research: Implications for
Meeting the Needs of Diverse Learners." Education
vol. 119, 4, Summer 1999, p. 682+ I printed this out for you.
Greenleaf,
Robert K. "Motion and Emotion in Student Learning."
The Education Digest, vol. 69, 1, Sept 2003, p. 37+ "Researchers
have now articulated the connection between emotion and learning:
Positive emotion may alter memory organization so that cognitive
material is better integrated and diverse ideas are seen as more
related." I printed this out for you.
Jorgenson,
Olaf. "Brain Scam? Why Educators Should be Careful
about Embracing 'Brain Research'" The Educational
Forum, vol. 67, 4, Summer 2003, p. 364+ "The vast majority
of brain-research information has been packaged and presented
by energetic, visionary educational consultants, almost none of
whom carry credentials in neuro-science or the study of brain
chemistry or anatomy." I printed this out for you.
Priggle,
Debra J. "20 Ways to Promote Brain-Based Teaching
and Learning." Intervention in School and Clinic,
vol. 37, 4, March 2002, p. 237-241. Not the greatest article,
but illustrates how educators write articles full of suggestions
"based on what is currently known about the brain."
Includes a long list of "Resources for Brain-Based Teaching
and Learning." I printed this out for you.
Roberts,
Jay W. "Beyond Learning By Doing: The Brain Compatible
Approach." The Journal of Experiential Education,
vol. 25, 2, Fall 2002, p. 281-285. I printed this out for you.
Taylor,
Edward W. "Transformative Learning Theory: A Neurobiological
Perspective of the Role of Motions and Unconscious Ways of Knowing."
International Journal of Lifelong Education, vol. 20,
3, May/June 2001, p. 218-236. I printed this out for you.
New
as of 4/26/04
Davis, Andrew. "The Credentials of Brain-Based Learning."
Journal of Philosophy of Education, vol. 38, 1, Feb. 2004,
p. 21+ "The heart of the paper tries to show how the contribution
of brain science to our grasp of the nature of learning is limited
in principle." (from the abstract) I sent for this on ILL.
It has come in (5/6/04). It's a philosophical argument; makes the
argument that education and learning take place in a broad, social
context. Gluck,
Mark A. Gateway to Memory: An Introduction to Neural
Network Modeling of the Hippocampus and Learning.
Cambridge: MIT Press, 2001. One of the more frequently recommended
"scientific" books on the topic. I suspect it will be
too technical, at least for me. I sent for it on ILL. I'll let
you know when it comes in.
New
as of 5/6/04
101st
CONGRESS, 1st
Session H. J. RES. 174 JOINT RESOLUTION
To designate the decade beginning January 1, 1990, as the `Decade
of the Brain'.
Brandt, Ron. "Educators Need to Know about the Human
Brain." Phi Delta Kappan, vol. 81, 3, Nov.
1999, p. 235+ Response to John Bruer's 1999
article.I printed this out for you.
BrightHouse
Neurostrategies Group. This is a company, founded in 2001
"to develop the next important evolution in market research
by harnessing the power of modern scientific approaches in ways
that can deliver unprecedented consumer insights." Offers
clients "more confidence and accuracy in marketing decisions
through a better understanding of how the brain mediates consumer
preference and purchase behavior." I printed out the company's
homepage. Just to let you know that these kinds of commercial
efforts exist.
Bruer, John
T. "Neural Connections: Some You Use, Some You Lose."
Phi Delta Kappan, vol. 81, 4, Dec. 1999, p. 264+ Bruer
discusses what he sees as "myths" that educators have
latched on to about "building better brains." I printed
this out for you. Bruer has also published a book, The Myth
of the First Three Years, which the library has (BF318.B79
1999).
Caskey, Micki
M., and Barbara Ruben. "Research for Awakening Adolescent
Learning." Education Digest, vol. 69, 4,
Dec. 2003, p. 36+ "Outlines ways in which educators can use
brain research for the purpose of informing instruction."
An example of this kind of paper written by people on the education
side. I printed this out for you.
Center
for Cognitive Neuroscience at Dartmouth College.
Cognitive
Neuroscience Society.
Dana
Alliance for Brain Initiatives. The link here is to their
"BrainWeb and Brain Information" section.
Education
Commission of the States and The Charles A. Dana Foundation. Bridging
the Gap Between Neuroscience and Education. Summary
of a Workshop cosponsored by Education Commission of the States
and the Charles A.Dana Foundation. "Workshop participants
concluded that neuroscientific findings probably do have implications
for education, but there is a chasm between what scientists accept
as proven fact and what the public, teachers and administrators
believe." I printed this out for you.
Goswami,
Usha. "Annual Review: Neuroscience and Education."
British Journal of Educational Psychology, vol.
74, part 1, Mar. 2004, p. 1-15. "Although current brain science
technologies offer exciting opportunities to educationists, they
complement rather than replace traditional methods of education
enquiry." Discusses "neuromyths." I printed this
out for you.
Klein, William
S. "Asimov Saw It Coming: Picking a Voter's Brain."
Christian Science Monitor 23 April 2004, p.
9. and Ferguson, Bill. "Brain Scans Being Used to
design Political Ads." Knight Ridder Tribune
News Service, 23 April 2004, p. 1. This is very new stuff.
Just to let you know about this kind of "research."
(You can see that I'm skeptical.) I clipped printouts of these
two news articles together; filed under Klein.
Krieger,
Lisa M. "Some Question Value of Brain Scans."
Mercury News 04 May 2004. "Brain scans are being
marketed in San Jose..." Silicon
Valley Brain SPECT Imaging, Inc. is the company being written
about. [Also has the URL: braininspect.com] I printed this article
out for you.
Society
for Neuroscience. "Advancing the Understanding of the
Brain and Nervous System."
Smith, Deborah.
"Science's Mind Games." The Age,
10 April 2004. Expanding field of brain research, in which Australian
sciences "feature prominently." "Overseas research
has shown brain imaging is able to identify racist attitudes,
lying, people's responses to movies and erotica, and even why
they prefer Coke to Pepsi." I printed this out for you.
Talaris
Research Institute. Established with $91 million from a telecommunications
billionaire (Bruce McCaw), "Telaris Research Institute is
dedicated to discovering how children think, feel and learn. ...These
ideas have the potential to change the way we parent our children
and how we educate people of any age" I printed out their
homepage.
Understanding
the Brain: Towards a New Learning Science. Paris:
OECD, 2002. I sent for this on ILL. It has arrived. I photocopied
a lot of it for you. It has sections about "separating science
from speculation."
Wesson,
Kenneth.
Educational consultant, neuroscience. ScienceMaster.
New as of
5/13/04
Handelsman, Jo, et al. "Scientific Teaching"
Science 304, 23 April 2004, p. 521-522. A "Policy
Forum" article urging that science teaching be reformed to
emphasize "active learning strategies to engage students
in the process of science and teaching methods that have be systematically
tested and shown to reach diverse students." Supplemental
materials are available online. Reading this article (which
is a sort-of call to arms) reminded me of the new science course
I heard was being developed for the WDBA.
|
Diversity
|| New
as of 3/26/04 || New as of 4/03/04 ||
New as of 4/17/04 || New as
of 4/28/04 || New as of 5/5/04
Web
sites
With
Diploma in Hand: Hispanic High School Seniors Talk About Their
Future, by John Immerwahr. Study done by Public
Agenda for National Center for Public Policy and Higher Education.
Includes a section on "Obstacles to College Attendance and
Completion." I printed this section out for you (filed under
title With Diploma...). You might want to skim the whole
report at the Web site.
Women,
Minorities, and Persons with Disabilities in Science and Engineering
-- 2002 From NSF. Latest biennial study. Formats:
HTML, and PDF.
Articles,
etc.
Auerbach, Susan. "'Why Do They Give the
Good Classes to Some and Not to Others?' Latino Parent Narratives
of Struggle in a College Access Program." Teachers
College Record vol. 104, 7, Oct. 2002, p. 1369+ I printed
this out for you. See, especially, "Implications for Policy
and Practice," p. 1389.
Bonous-Hammarth,
Marguerite. "Pathways to Success: Affirming Opportunities
for Science, Mathematics, and Engineering Majors. The
Journal of Negro Education vol. 69, 1/2, Winter 2000, p.
92+ I printed this out for you.
Brown, Sarita
E., et al. "Latinos in Higher Education: Today and
Tomorrow." Change, vol. 35, 2, Mar/Apr
2003, p. 40+ I printed this out for you. Includes interesting
numbers and bits of info, e.g., p. 3 talks about 200 institutions
that have been identified as HSIs (Hispanic-Serving Institutions).
Includes a list of Action Recommendations (which are a bit general).
Cabrera,
Alberto F. et al. "Collaborative Learning: Its Impact
on College Students' Development and Diversity."
Journal of College Student Development, Jan/Feb 2002,
vol. 43, 1, p. 20+ I printed this out for you.
Covington,
Martin V. Goal Theory, Motivation, and School Achievement:
An Integrative Review." Annual Review of Psychology,
vol. 51, 2000, p. 171-200. Good, overall review of the literature.
I printed this out for you.
Hall, Ronald
E. and George T. Rowan. "Hispanic-American Males
in Higher Education: A Descriptive/Qualitative Analysis."
Education vol. 121, 3, Spring 2001, p. 565+ I printed
this out for you. Quite a good review of the literature (p. 2-4).
Abstract begins with this: "Hispanic-American males encounter
various forms of oppression in higher education..."
Jacobson,
Linda Olson. "Valuing Diversity: Student-Teacher
Relationships that Enhance Achievement." Community
College Review vol. 28, 1, Summer 2000, p. 49+ I printed
this out for you.
Padilla,
Raymond V., et al., "Developing Local Models of Minority
Student Success in College." Journal of College
Student Development vol. 38, 2, p. 125+ I printed this out
for you. Presents an "expertise model" for minority
student success (which is different from the Tinto model).
Shultz, Eileen
L. et al., "The Adventor Program: Advisement and
Mentoring for Students of Color in Higher Education."
Journal of Humanistic Counceling, Education and
Development, vol. 40, 2, Fall 2001, p. 208+ I printed this
our for you.
Strage, Amy.
"Predictors of College Adjustment and Success: Similarities
and Differences among Southeast-Asian-American, Hispanic and White
Students." Education vol. 120, 4, Summer
2000, p. 731+ I printed this out for you. See p.2-3 for a review
of the literature.
Wallace,
David L. and Annissa Bell. "Being Black at a Predominantly
White University." College English, vol.
61, 3, p. 307+ I printed this out for you.
Weissman,
Julie et al. "A Study of White, Black, and Hispanic
Students' Transition to a Community College." Community
College Review vol. 26, 2, Fall 1998, p. 19+ I printed this
out for you.
The
following are more general articles are about diversity in higher
education:
Does
Diversity Make a Difference? Three Research Studies on Diversity
in College Classrooms (pdf file) From ACE's Center
for Advancement of Racial & Ethnic Equity
Blimling,
Gregory S. "Editorial: Diversity Makes You Smarter."
Journal of College Student Development. Nov/Dec
2001, vol. 42, 6, p. 517+ "Within the past few years, the
argument for increasing diversity on college campuses has changed.
With more than 20 years of research to examine, consensus appears
to be building that diversity has strong academic benefits for
students." Summary of this research. Citations to important
studies. I printed out this article for you.
Kao, Grace,
and Jennifer S. Thompson. "Racial and Ethnic Stratification
in Educational Achievement and Attainment." Annual
Review of Sociology, 2003, vol. 29, 1, p. 417+. I printed
this out for you.
Meacham,
Jack et al. "Student Diversity in Classes and Educational
Outcomes: Student Perceptions." College Student
Journal, 2003, vol. 37, 4, p. 627+ I printed this out for
you.
Pascarella,
Ernest et al. "Do Diversity Experiences Influence
the Development of Critical Thinking?" Journal
of College Student Development. May/Jun 2001, vol. 42, 3;
p. 257+ I printed this out for you.
Shinn, Marybeth and Siobhan M. Toohey. "Community
Contexts of Human Welfare." Annual Review of
Psychology, vol. 54, 2003, p. 427+ I printed this out for
you.
Studies
-- would you want to buy?
American
Council on Education -- Center for Advancement of Racial &
Ethnic Equity
The
Continuing Significance of Racism: U.S. Colleges and Universities
(published 2002) First in a New Series of Occasional
Papers from ACE "In the last 20 years, the atmosphere on
U.S. college campuses has changed significantly for minority students.
Yet while access to higher education may have widened, the graduation
rates for some underrepresented groups still lag behind those
of Caucasians, and the rates of attendance and success in graduate
programs show even greater gaps."
Minorities
in Higher Education 2002-2003: Twentieth Annual
Status Report (2003)
Diversity
in IT industry
Diversity
in the IT Industry from IMDiversity
Diversity
in IT from Network World Fusion (10/03) about ITAA's diversity
study based on data from the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics; scroll
down to get the full report
Diversity
in Information Technology is a conference coming up in May 2004
of the Information Resources Management Association International
Conference
New
as of 3/26/04
American
Diploma Project I printed out the executive summary for you.
The project is interested in what graduating high school seniors
actually need to know to be successful in higher education and in
the workforce.
Anonymous. "From
Remediation to Acceleration: Raising the Bar in Developmental
Education." Change, vol. 31, 1, Jan/Feb
1999, p. 57+ I printed this out for you. "too little is known
about the content and delivery of remedial education nationwide
or the features of successful programs for the underprepared."
Refers to Henry Levin and "accelerated schools."
Anonymous.
"New National Task Force to Address Lack of Hispanics
in Science, Technology." Black Issues in Higher
Education, vol. 20, 17, Oct. 9, 2003, p. 11. I printed this
out for you. The article says that HACU got a $100,000 grant from
NSF; they have appointed 12 top educators from HACU-member colleges
and universities "to address the need to increase the ranks
of Hispanics in science, technology, engineering, and math."
Here's their Web site: Hispanic
Association of Colleges and Universities (HACU) The Web site
includes statistics about Hispanics, and about Hispanics in education.
Information about conferences.I don't see anything at the Web
site about this project, but you could probably contact them through
info at the Web site. Dr. Gustave Roig (Florida International
Univ.) and Dr. Maria Elena Zavala (CSU-Northridge) co-chair the
taskforce.
Chubin, Daryl
E. and Eleanor Babco. "Walking the Talk" in
Retention-to-graduation: Institutional Production of Minority
Engineers -- A NACME Analysis. July 2003. I printed this
out for you.
Diversity
Web -- "The most comprehensive compendium of campus practices
and resources about diversity in higher education." They
have a Web page (with links) on Recruitment,
Retention and Mentoring.
ETS (Educational
Testing Service). Parsing
the Achievement Gap: Baselines for Tracking Progress.
issued Nov. 2003. I will print this out for you if you like. "ETS’s
Policy Information Center identifies the factors before, during
and after school that create and perpetuate the well-documented
gaps in achievement among students from different racial and ethnic
backgrounds and different family income levels..."
The
Foundation Coalition (FC) is one of 8 engineering coalitions
funded by the NSF; it was established as an "agent of systemic
renewal for the engineering educational community." Their
Web page on Participation
of Women and Underrepresented Minorities in Engineering.
Hamrick,
Florence A., and Frances K. Stage. "College Predisposition
at High-Minority Enrollment, Low-Income Schools."
Review of Higher Education, Winter 2004, vol. 27, 2,
p. 151+ I printed this out for you. Reviews the student college
choice research.
Increasing
Diversity in the Sciences: What Works! Web-based papers from
a conference held September 23, 2002
Matthews,
Frank. "Working with What Works." Black
Issues in Higher Education, vol. 13, 26,
2/20/97, p. 31+ I
printed out this article for you. The College Board established
Equity 2000 in 1990
-- a program to help get more students onto a college track.Focus
was on mathematics in high school -- to get minorities to succeed
in pre-collegiate math. In the late 1990s, Dr. Vinetta Jones (Equity
2000's Executive Director) was interviewed: "we are just
moving now to national dissemination." Equity 2000 disseminated
by working with specific school districts. Today (3/25/04), the
Web site at The College Board is named Equity & Excellence.
The Web site says that "over 35 school districts nationally
utilize our suite of professional development workshops."
Click to go to EQUITY
2000: A Systemic Education Reform Model
The Web site announces that it is now under new
leadership and going in a new direction.
May, Gary S., and Daryl E. Chubin. "A Retrospective
on Undergraduate Engineering Success for Underrepresented Minority
Students." Journal of Engineering Education,
vol. 92, 1, Jan. 2003, p. 27+ I printed this out for you. The
article explores" past and current paradigms...analyzing
models for advancing the particpation of members of these populations."
Programs examined: California Minority Engineering Program (MEP),
which "has been propagated for nearly thirty years, and has
been successfully replicated at over 100 universities..."
National
Science Foundation. Commission on the Advancement of Women and
Minorities in Science, Engineering, and Technology Development
(CAWMSET). Commission
Report and Brochure. 2000. The report is 104 pages
long. You could scan it online and ask me to print out various
sections.
Olson, David
R. "The Triumph of Hope Over Experience in the Search
for 'What Works': A Response to Slavin" Educational
Researcher, vol. 33,1, Jan/Feb 2004, p. 24+ I printed this
out for you. You just might want some background on the evidence-based
arguments, and I think the Olson-Slavin pieces provide that.
Payton, Fay
Cobb. "Making STEM Careers More Accessible."
Black Issues in Higher Education, 11 Mar. 2004, vol.
21, 2, p. 4. Discusses "barriers to entry for ...underrepresented
groups in STEM careers" I printed this out for you.
Pennington,
Hilary. "Study Reveals Strengths, Weaknesses in Improving
Rates of High School Graduation & college Completion for Law-Income
& Minority Students." U.S. Newswire, 24 Oct.
2003, p. 1. I printed this out for you. Refers to a study titled
"Double the Numbers," which I also printed out for you.
(In pile under its title, "Double...")
Roach, Ronald.
"Losing Ground." Black Issues in
Higher Education, 11 Mar. 2004, vol. 21, 2, p. 28+ "After
more than a decade of steady enrollments and degree completion
rates by underrepresented minorities...agencies still face a daunting
task..." Refers to a 2003 report Walking the Talk in
Retention-to-Graduation Institutional Production of Minority Engineers
from the National Action Council for Minorities in engineering,
Inc. (NACME). Authors are Chubin and Babco. I printed this article
and the NACME report out for you.
Rodriguez,
James L. et al. "Promoting Academic Achievement and
Identify Development Among Diverse High School Students."
The High School Journal, vol. 87, 3, Feb/Mar
2004, p. 44. I printed this article out for you. Describes a program
that is guided by social interaction principles, e.g., scaffolded
learning.
Slavin, Robert
E. "Evidence-Based Education Policies." Educational
Researcher, vol. 31, 1, Oct 2002, p. 15+ Argues
strongly that "educational research has produced ...very
few rigorous studies of programs and practices that could serve
as a solid base for policy and practice..." and that there
is a need to "focus on replicable programs and practices..."
I printed this out for you. His arguments are opposed by Olson
(see above) in Olson's "The Triumph of Hope..."
Slavin, Robert
E. "Education Research Can and Must Address 'What
Works' Questions." Educational Researcher,
33, 1, Jan/Feb 2004, p. 27+ I printed this out for you.
Smittle,
Patricia. "Principles for Effective Teaching in Developmental
Education" Journal of Developmental Education,
vol. 26, 3, p. 10+ I printed this out for you. There's quite a
literature on teaching in developmental education, which includes
all students that are underprepared. This article sort of summarizes
much of the research that talks about what principles seem to
work best in these environments.
Youngman,
J.A. and C. J. Egelhoff. Best Practices in Recruiting
and Persistence of Underrepresented Minorities in Engineering:
A 2002 Snapshot. I printed this out for you. Discusses
2 models -- Model B is to recruit "educationally disadvantaged"
students. Identifies best practices of programs.
New
as of 4/03/04
Castellanos, Jeanett and Lee Jones, eds. The
Majority in the Minority: Expanding the Representation of Latina/o
Faculty, Administrators and Students in Higher Education.
Sterling, VA:
Stylus, 2003. This book covers, in detail, data and programs in
relation to Hispanics in higher education. I photocopied a good
portion of the book for you. Amaury Nora wrote the chapter "Access
to Higher Education for Hispanic Students: Real or Illusory?"
He is at the Univ. of Houston. I will add him to the list of people
I think you should think about contacting directly.
Cooper, Catherine R.
"Five Bridges Along Students' Pathways to College: A Developmental
Blueprint of Families, teachers, Counselors, Mentors, and Peers
in the Puente Project." You have a copy of this
(I gave it to you on 4/2/04) Discusses the component bridges mentioned
in the article title, for Puente students.
Schmidt,
Peter. "Academe's Hispanic Future."
The Chronicle of Higher Education, vol. 50, 14, 28 Nov.
2003, p. A8. I printed out this article for you.
Strauss,
Linda C. and J. Fredericks Volkwein. "Predictors
of Student Commitment at Two-Year and Four-Year Institutions."
The Journal of Higher Education, vol. 75, 2, Mar/Apr
2004, p. 203+ I sent for a copy of this on ILL.
new
as of 4/17/04
Education Commission of the States. Closing
the College Participation Gap. Oct. 2003.
Educational
Testing Service. Education
= Success: Empowering Hispanic Youth and Adults. (1999)
National Center for Education
Statistics. Participation
in Remedial Education (2003)
National
Center for Education Statistics. Status
and Trends in the Education of Hispanics. (2003)
National
Center for Public Policy and Education The Educational
Pipeline: Big Investment, Big Returns (April 6, 2004) is
one of their documents. It shows, for example, that California
ranks 31st among the states in students entering college after
high school. I printed out this "Policy Alert" for you.
Also at this site -- UNDERPREPARED
STUDENTS
by Robert McCabe-- which includes this statement: "Eighty
percent of new jobs will require some postsecondary education
but, unfortunately, only 42% of today's students leave high school
with the necessary skills to begin college-level work." McCabe
argues for remedial (or developmental) education. I printed out
McCabe's piece for you. NOTE: the national office of the National
Center for Public Policy and Education has a San Jose Office:
152 North Third Street, Suite 705
San Jose, California 95112
Telephone: 408-271-2699
FAX: 408-271-2697
EMail: jdemaria@highereducation.org
National
Science Board. Realizing
America's Potential. Report describes student interest
in STEM fields as "flat or reduced" despite more than
a decade of efforts. Between 1975 and 1999, U.S. went from 3rd
to 14th place in proportion of 24 yr olds having STEM degrees.
New
as of 4/28/04
Daempfle, Peter A. "An Analysis of the High Attrition
Rates Among First Year College Science, Math, and Engineering
Majors." Journal of College Student Retention,
vol. 5, 1, 2003-2004, p. 37-52. Review of studies as to why there
is a decline of interest in STEM majors, despite all the efforts
that have been made to interest students in these fields. I got
a copy of this article for you on interlibrary loan.
Levin, M.
and J. Levin. "A Critical Examination of Academic
Retention Programs for At-Risk Minority College Students."
Journal of College Student Development vol. 32, 1991,
p. 323-334. This is the article you asked me about in an email
on 4/28/04; I'm sending for it ILL. It has come in (5/7/04) and
I've put it in your next pile to photocopies to pick up.
New
as of 5/5/04
McCabe,
Robert H. Yes We Can! A Community College Guide to Developing
America's Underprepared. Phoenix, AZ: League for Innovation
in the Community College, 2003. I requested this on ILL. The book
is here (5/5/04), as I've told you in an email. I've photocopied
the contents page, the first chapter, and the book's bibliography,
but I think you'll want to peruse the book yourself.
Topsy's notes
(sort of to myself):
1. Watch for information about these Higher Education Act
programs that reach out to Hispanic students: TRIO and
GEAR-UP. Found: see above.
2. The Majority in the Minority: Expanding the Representation
of Latina/o Faculty, Administrators and Students in Higher Education
-- I've requested this book on interlibrary loan (ILL). Received
the book. Photocopied selected parts for you.
3. What Makes Racial Diversity Work in Higher Education
-- I've requested this book on ILL.
Received. 4.
"Five Bridges Along Students' Pathways to College"
I've requested this article on ILL. First sentence of the abstract
"What program components might enhance the effectiveness in
promoting college access for all students?" Includes longitudinal
case studies of Puente students. |